Welcome! | Ask A Question

 
 
Question

Asked 9/3/2011

Non-biolgical male is taking us to court saying he is the biological father of mine and my husbands daughter.

A man I have known my whole life is taking me and my husband to court to prove that he is the biological father of our daughter. Our daughter is almost 7 yoa and there was a 6 mo period between the time this man and I were together, while my husband and I were seperated and getting divorced, and the time I got pregnant with my daughter, by my husband. Recently this man contacted me, saying he believed that he was her father and wanted to take a paternity test, after a while, and much harrasement, I agreed, thinking after it came back negative that he would drop it and leave us alone. The test was conducted by ourselves, no gloves, it was done in the car in a parking lot, and I swabbed my daughters mouth and left. I did not witness, the rest of the test. (stupid on my part- I know) The test came back positive. My husband and I with our daughter went to a licensed DNA service to conduct our own test, that came back positive and is admissable in court. This male has now taken us to court, and is relentless, trying desperately to prove that our daughter is his, which clearly she is not. He also issued an injunction against me saying that he was in fear that I may take our daughter out of the country, I have not been able to leave our county for months now. Is there a way he could have cheated on the DNA test, and Is there anything that my husband and I can do to protect ourselves and most importanly our daughter from this, insane man?

 
 
 
 
Answers

Answer 1/9 - Submitted 9/3/2011

I would tell him that you require a proper and legal test done, at his expense, and that if it comes back negative and he continues you will counter sue for the stress he has put you though. And that you will try to get a restraining order against him.

Of course it its possitive you should be asking him to pay for child support for years past.

Did you see the results of the test he had done? Or did he simply tell you the results.

I suppose if he was a twin of your husband? To cheat he would have required your husbands DNA.

Good luck, it does sound like the guy is a bit nuts.. but if there is any chance he is the father - you had best be prepared.

 
 

Answer 2/9 - Submitted 9/3/2011

If you did a test that proved your husband was the father then this man could have gotten your husband's DNA somehow. Someone who is this overzealous about proving the child is his, I wouldn't put it past him to stalk your husband and wait for the day he spits out a piece of gum, drops a coffee cup in the trash or any other variety of activities which leave our DNA laying around in places that are easy to get to. All he'd have to do was scoop up that item and swab it for his swab and get that tested. There's absolutely no proof that it was his DNA that was on his swab. And really, if you had a test done that proved your husband is the father, then there's no way the DNA on his swab was his. Heck, it might not have even been your daughter's DNA on her swab when he sent them in.

Take him to court and demand that a DNA test be done, on his dime, and by a reputable company, not in a parking lot where he controls the swabs before and after. When it comes back negative get a restraining order against him, as it's obvious he did something to screw up the original DNA test so that he could keep harassing your family. Make sure it includes all forms of communication - including phones, e-mail, instant message, letters, physical contact, etc. Include your whole family - the people living with you - on this order. If he ever violates it, in any way, call the police immediately. Do not humor this insane man anymore than you have to!

As soon as the court-ordered DNA test comes back negative the courts will release you from not being allowed out of the country, as he has no claim to a child that is not his and cannot stop you from travelling with her.

 
 

Answer 3/9 - Submitted 9/4/2011

If your DNA test from a lab says your daughter is your husbands then you have are fine. You need to like a previous poster said file a restraining order against him for harasssing you and your family. Because once the lab says your husband if the child's father their is nothing more to argue get a restraining order and move on with your life.

 
 

Answer 4/9 - Submitted 9/4/2011

It sounds as though you have had two tests? the first could have been a mistake or meddled with, but you say that the second was just you and your husband, and it still came back positive for the other man. Are you sure that you are not just in denial? if two seperate tests come back positive, then it seems to me that he must be the father. or did you mean your husband? I think the best thing you can do is take the test again, just you and your husband, in a hospital environment, and if it proves the other man is the father then make arrangements with all three of you sitting down amicably. If this is not possible then take it to a court to decide what to do. If he is not the father, then get an injunction.

 
 

Answer 5/9 - Submitted 9/4/2011

The test that my husband and daughter took, was preformed at a medical DNA service center, in accordence with the aabb spefications. We had to provide thumb prints, birth certificate, ss card, and a photo of the two were taken and everything was submitted togehther. The test came back positive that my husband is her biological father, and is admissable in court. This test has been submitted to the court, but still we are tangled up in court. I tried to get a restraining order but was denied, because there was no repeat violence. We have adivsedthe school, that under NO circumstance is anyone to pick her up from school other than my husband and I. We just want to know where do we go from here and why has the court not dismissed the case?

 
 

Answer 6/9 - Submitted 9/4/2011

Hi, rr1028, and welcome to WebAnswers.

While I realize that this ordeal has been stressful to you, please understand that, from a legal perspective, nothing is admissible in a court of law until a court makes that determination, and it is likely that your "friend" has objected to this being entered into evidence.

The court may very well seek yet another test from a lab of ITS choosing before deciding the matter, no matter how ludicrous this issue may appear to you to be. The court does not take sides, does not know what it is that you might know, and, until it feels confident that it has all the facts of the matter, only then will it make a ruling.

So, where you go from here is to wait the court's decision, assuming you have an attorney.

If, on the other hand, you do not have counsel, then you should go to the clerk's office and read the file to see if anything is amiss. You should then undertake to do this on a weekly basis until the matter is resolved.

 
 

Answer 7/9 - Submitted 9/4/2011

If you can already prove that your husband is the father of your daughter, and have already payed to have a legally admissible DNA test done ... then what this man is doing is just harassment.

I would just sue him outright for harassment and get a restraining order placed against hime for you and your daughter (If he is this delusional, you need to protect yourself and your daughter). No one can just "claim" to be the father and get an injunction placed one another person. There has to be proof. His "test' would not stand up in a court against your professional test ... so i don't even see how he could have placed an injunction against you.

Start taking legal action against him for harassment. And protect yourself.

Hope this helps.

 
 

Answer 8/9 - Submitted 9/5/2011

Great advice!

 
 

Answer 9/9 - Submitted 9/5/2011

Sailor4life,
That's what we can't figure out. He got the restraining order by saying that I have family in New Zealand and and that I was planning on leaving the country! I have no family in another country, much less New Zealand, nor do I know anyone in another country, nor do any of us have passports!

We paid $500 bucks to have our test done right and professionally, in accordence with the law.

I did not met the qualifications in my state for an injunction! So we must live in fear everyday!
I'm just wondering how much longer this is gonna go on. Now we just got to make the decision to take legal action against him, or just let it go,once the judge tells him he is not our daughter's biological father.

Thanks to everyone for your advice and comments.

 
 
 
 
Answer This Question Now

Type your Answer in the box below and post your answer.

Learn more about how this works

 
 
 

Related Questions (Ask a New Question)

 
Possible assessd tax

Will there be tax assessed if i should sell 10 years of an annuity from a civil settlement to a company that specializes in such deals?

See Answers

 
Annuity distribution from a deat benefit

My mother passed away recently and i have received a death benefit package from hartford annuity where she had her contract. i am going to receive a lump sum payment.should i have let hartford take out the 25% to cover my tax liability or should i just have tehm send me the intire amount and report...

See Answers

 
Which form?

I have alimony and annuity income in 2007. can i still use the 1040 form to report this?

See Answers

 
Related Questions

Possible assessd tax


Will there be tax assessed if i should sell 10 years of an annuity from a civil settlement...

 

Annuity distribution from a deat benefit


My mother passed away recently and i have received a death benefit package from hartford annuity...

 

Which form?


I have alimony and annuity income in 2007. can i still use the 1040 form to report this?

 

Pension fund for police dept.


I sit on a pension board for the local, police dept, we would like to buy an annuity for...

 

Annuity


My dad passed away and my mom received $34,000 from an annuity in his name. must she pay...

 

Taxable portion of survivor's annuity


I am receiving $13,884 annually as a survivor annuity, due to the death of my husband (former...

 
 

See more Annuity questions

 
 
 
 
 

Ask A Question

Ask a new question about
Annuity: